Voice of a rock. Testimony’s importance as a discursive genre in the recognition of obstetric violence
Keywords:
obstetric violence, testimony, discursive genres, discourse, vulnerability.Abstract
The article studies an experience of obstetric violence. I analyze the discursive construction from Das's heuristic proposal on testimony, in dialogue with Bakhtin's work about discursive genres. I propose that the testimony is an intimate discursive genre that has political potential, since the person who enunciates it, publicly exposes her vulnerability; In this act, subjectivity, anchored in moral precepts, plays an important role in dismantling the official model of the world, according to Bakhtin. In the testimony, a vision of the world that confronts the dominant norms is exposed. Inés, my interlocutor, shows in her narrative a dispute between the relevance of "medical action" versus the "embodied experience of childbirth." The message gains discursive power through dialogical relations (change of discursive subjects) together with a tendency to "fusion between the speaker and the addressee", characteristic of Bakhtin's intimate styles. Based on this analysis, I propose that in order to understand obstetric violence and its significance process, it is necessary to: situate the experience in the life trajectory of those who have incarnated experienced the exercise of obstetric power in the framework of the Mexican national State in which violence against women is a widespread phenomenon.
Downloads
References
Bajtin, M., T. Bubnova y G.?S. Bemshtein, Estética de la creación verbal, 2a. ed., rev. (México: Siglo XXI Editores [Lingüística y Teoría Literaria], 2012 [1952-1953]), 284.
Bernstein, R. J., Violencia: pensar sin barandillas. Serie Cla-de-ma. Filosofía (Barcelona: Gedisa, 2015).
Butler, Judith, y Horacio Pons, Dar cuenta de sí mismo. Violencia ética y responsabilidad (Buenos Aires / Madrid: Amorrortu [Mutaciones], 2012), 24.
Das, V., Sujetos del dolor, agentes de dignidad, Bogotá / Medellín: Pontificia Universidad Javeriana Instituto Pensar / Universidad Nacional de Colombia-Facultad de Ciencias Humanas y Económicas / Universidad Nacional de Colombia-Facultad de Ciencias Humanas, Centro de Estudios Sociales [Lecturas, CES], 2008);
Felman, Shoshana, y Dori Laub: Testimony. Crises of witnessing in literature, psychoanalysis, and history (Nueva York: Routledge, 1991).
Gilson, E., “Vulnerability, ignorance, and oppression”, Hypatia, vol. 26, núm. 2 (2011), 308-332, 310, acceso el 5 de octubre de 2022, http://www.jstor.org/stable/23016548.
Jakobson, R., J. M. Pujol y J. Cabanes, Ensayos de lingüística general: XV Lingüística y poética, 2a. ed. (Barcelona: Seix Barral [Biblioteca Breve, 381, Ciencias Humanas] 1981), 383.
Sexagésima Primera Legislatura Constitucional del Estado Libre y Soberano de Guanajuato, “Ley de Acceso de las Mujeres a una Vida Libre de Violencia para el Estado de Guanajuato”, Periódico Oficial del Gobierno del Estado de Guanajuato, 21 de octubre de 2020, artículo 5.viii (reformado, 13 de julio de 2020), acceso el 5 de octubre de 2022, https://legislacion.scjn.gob.mx/buscador/paginas/wfArticuladoFast.aspx?q=53E5PvVpljaUSQiybXXEcOQ6A6KTzJx79wzyJcwK2fCfEVgH+40VB4DfQQXInVDmKvmip6lrFCqdPURkWW1z5w==.