No. 8 (2019): Conversaciones... con Herb Stovel
Artículos

Authenticity and the localness of heritage: emerging perceptions at World Heritage sites in Africa

PDF
  • Pascall Taruvinga

Published 2020-05-20

Keywords

  • authenticity,
  • localness,
  • conservation,
  • World Heritage,
  • indigenous knowledge

How to Cite

Authenticity and the localness of heritage: emerging perceptions at World Heritage sites in Africa. (2020). Conversaciones con. , 8, 123-141. https://revistas.inah.gob.mx/index.php/conversaciones/article/view/15673

Abstract

Cultural heritage in Africa is viewed as a local phenomenon embedded in the rich and diverse Indigenous Knowledge Systems of local communities. It reflects the pioneering spirit and approaches of local communities in defining the localness and character of heritage. However, colonialism almost erased this localness in Africa through advancing the monumentality approach, further reinforced by the World Heritage concept until recent times. To address this issue, the authenticity concept was adopted as a way of restoring the localness and character of cultural heritage. Through this concept, the African cultural heritage provides local perspectives and insights into the discourse on authenticity. Robben Island World Heritage site (South Africa), offers cross-cutting local perspectives and insights on authenticity. This discussion emphasises understanding the dynamics between authenticity and inscription process, obtaining and safeguarding information sources, conservation, sustainable development and heritage curriculums. The paper recommends adopting a progressive and adaptive approach to broaden the concept of authenticity as a continuing process linked to the ever-changing cultural practices at the local, which gives birth to ‘current authenticity’. This reinforces the importance of emerging local perspectives on authenticity and local communities in the future implementation of World Heritage in Africa.

PDF

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

  1. Abungu, George (2014) Looking at the traditional heritage conservation and management systems: the case of the Rabai Sacred Kaya Forests, Kenya, Unpublished paper, Paper presented at the NARA+20 Workshop, July 2014, Cape Town, South Africa.
  2. Abungu, George O. (2015) “Introduction”, in: George Abungu (ed.), Traditional management systems at World Heritage sites in Africa, Midrand, South Africa, pp. 15-22.
  3. African World Heritage Fund (2014) Report of the Nara document workshop that was held in Cape Town, South Africa from 8 to 9 July 2014, Midrand, South Africa.
  4. Chirikure, Shadreck (2014) Nara document, heritage training and research: an African perspective, Unpublished paper, Paper presented at the NARA+20 Workshop, July 2014, Cape Town, South Africa.
  5. Chirikure, Shadreck, Tawanda Mukwende and Pascall Taruvinga (2015) “Post-colonial heritage conservation in Africa: perspectives from drystone wall restorations at Khami World Heritage Site, Zimbabwe”, International Journal of Heritage Studies 22 (2): 165-178.
  6. Entech (2003) Robben Island stone quarry: protection measures for quarry sites and stone wall. Consultancy report, Unpublished report submitted to Robben Island Museum, Cape Town, South Africa.
  7. Hart, Tim (2003) Conservation statement on proposed rehabilitation options, northwest quarry, Robben Island, Unpublished Report, Department of Archaeology, University of Cape Town.
  8. Jokilehto, Jukka and Joseph King (2000) Authenticity and integrity. Summary of ICCROM Position Paper, Amsterdam 1998 [https://whc.unesco.org/en/events/443/] (accessed on 25 March 2019).
  9. Jopela, Albino (2016) “The traditional custodianship system in Southern Africa”, in: George O. Abungu (ed.), Traditionalmanagement systems at heritage sites in Africa, Midrand, South Africa, pp. 23-55.
  10. Kigongo, Remigius and Andrew Reid (2007) “Local communities, politics and the management of the Kasubi tombs, Uganda”, World Archaeology 39 (3): 371-384.
  11. Lowenthal, David (1995) “Changing criteria of authenticity”, in: Knut Einar Larsen (ed.), Nara conference on authenticity - Conférence de Nara sur l’authenticité, Japan 1994, Proceedings, UNESCO World Heritage Centre/Agency for Cultural Affairs (Japan)/ICCROM/ICOMOS, Tapir Publishers, Trondheim, pp. 121-135.
  12. Mahachi, Godfrey and Ephraim Kamuhangire (2008) “Administrative arrangements for heritage resources management in sub-Saharan Africa”, in: Webber Ndoro, Albert Mumma and George Abungu (eds.), Cultural heritage and the law. Protecting immovable heritage in English-speaking countries of Sub-Saharan Africa, ICCROM Conservation Studies 8, ICCROM, Rome, pp. 43-51.
  13. Matenga, Edward (2004) Proposals for the conservation of a dry stone wall at the Blue Stone Quarry on Robben Island, Unpublished report, File 9/2/018/0004, SAHRA Archives.
  14. Mumma, Albert (2002) “Legal aspects of cultural landscape protection in Africa”, in: Cultural landscapes: the challenges of conservation, shared legacy. World Heritage Papers 7, UNESCO, Paris, pp. 156-159.
  15. Nara document on authenticity (1994) Nara document on authenticity [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nara_Document_on_Authenticity] (accessed on 25 march 2016).
  16. Ndlovu, Ndukuyakhe (2014) Authenticity and the application of the World Heritage Convention. Unpublished paper, Paper presented at the NARA+20 Workshop, July 2014, Cape Town, South Africa.
  17. UNESCO (2017) Operational Guidelines for the implementation of the World Heritage Convention, UNESCO, Paris.
  18. Robben Island Museum (2017) Draft Policy regulating Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) between Robben Island Museum and Ex-Political Prisoners. Robben Island Museum, Cape Town (South Africa), Unpublished document.
  19. Saouma-Forero, Galia (ed.) (2001) Authenticity and integrity in an African Context. Expert meeting, Great Zimbabwe, Zimbabwe, 26-29 May 2000, UNESCO, Paris.
  20. Stanley-Price, Nicholas and Joseph King (eds.) (2009) Conserving the authentic. Essays in honour of Jukka Jokilehto, ICCROM Conservation Studies 10, ICCROM, Rome.
  21. Stovel, Herb (2008) “Origins and influence of the Nara document on authenticity”, APT Bulletin 39 (2/3): 9-10.
  22. Taruvinga, Pascall and Souayibou Varissou (2013) Conservation practices at African World Heritage sites: the case of Kasubi Tombs and Great Zimbabwe, Midrand, South Africa - African World Heritage Fund. Unpublished Paper.
  23. Taruvinga, Pascall (2014) Conservation, Tourism and Social responsibility: Challenges of developing Robben Island World Heritage site as a sustainable ‘hybrid’ institution, Unpublished paper, Paper prepared for a Workshop on Heritage and Sustainable development, 2014, Morocco.
  24. Taruvinga, Pascall (2015) Local actors and their role in sustainable development at World Heritage sites in Africa, the case of Robben Island World Heritage Site, Cape Town, Robben Island.
  25. Taruvinga, Pascall (2017) Living heritage, contestations and conservation: the case of Robben Island World Heritage Site, South Africa, Cape Town, South Africa, Unpublished paper.
  26. Taruvinga, Pascall (2017) Building robust heritage industries: Making heritage responsive to socio-economic needs of African State Parties, Unpublished paper, Paper presented during the International Conference on African Cultures (ICAC 2017), National Art Gallery of Zimbabwe, 11-13 September 2017, Harare, Zimbabwe.
  27. Taruvinga, Pascall (2018) Building bridges between theory and practice; aligning university curriculums to the interdisciplinary needs of World Heritage sites: case of Robben Island World Heritage site, Unpublished paper, Paper Presented at the UNESCO “Workshop World Heritage and Educational Institutions in Africa”, 19-21 April 2018, Great Zimbabwe, Zimbabwe.
  28. Von Droste, Bernd (2012) “World Heritage and globalization: UNESCO’s contribution to the development of global ethics”, in: Marie-Theres Albert, Marielle Richon, Marie José Viñals and Andrea Witcomb (eds.), Community development through World Heritage, World Heritage Papers (31), UNESCO, Paris, pp. 10-15.